A Thought Stream Exposed

Saturday, September 10, 2005

    In my opinion, the most fundamental problem with most neural networks is a trait they share with AI programs. Both are fatally burdened by their focus on behavior. Whether they are calling these behaviors "answers," "patterns," or "outputs," both AI and neural networks assume intelligence lies in the behavior that a program or a neural network produces after processing a given input. The most important attribute of a computer program or a neural network is whether is gives the correct or desired output. As inspired by Alan Turing, intelligence equals behavior.
    But intelligence is not just a matter of acting or behaving intelligently. Behavior is a manifestation of intelligence, but not a central characteristic or primary definition of being intelligent. A moment's reflection proves this: You can be intelligent just lying in the dark, thinking and understanding. Ignoring what goes on in your head and focusing instead on behavior has been a large impediment to understanding intelligence and building intelligent machines.

- Jeff Hawkins, On Intelligence